Archive for September, 2008

Sam Decker Customer reviews improve intent-to-buy metrics for Cars.com

September 30th, 2008 by Sam Decker Chief Marketing Officer

This blog entry was guest written by Ashley Moreno, Marketing Analyst.

Conversion rates and other metrics help make measuring the effects of UGC on retail Web sites fairly intuitive. With our latest case study, we hoped to better understand the effects of Bazaarvoice Ratings & Reviews on non-retail sites, where proving ROI can seem more difficult. Specifically, we hoped to grasp how Ratings and Reviews affect consumer interest during the research phase of the buying cycle. Cars.com, a content-heavy site that provides easy to understand information to some 10 million car shoppers a month, served as a great test case.

While Cars.com does not sell anything on their site directly, they do provide consumers information to make well-informed buying decisions, and they display vehicle ads from dealers and private sellers across the country. To determine how the addition of Ratings and Reviews affected their consumer base, we looked at various intent-to-buy metrics, including:

  • Number of page views for lead-related “Thank You” pages
  • Click-through rates to dealer maps from inventory pages
  • Click rates to the “Finance and Loan” calculator from inventory pages

Inventory pages with reviews out-performed those without in each of these ready-to-purchase metrics:

  • Reviews improved lead conversion by 16%
  • Reviews doubled the click-through to dealer maps
  • Reviews increased visitors seeking financing options using the calculator by 45%

This illustrates that even businesses without sales on their site can examine other metrics to better understand how user-generated content affects later buying decisions, community, and consumer loyalty. Take a minute to read the full case study.

Sam Decker 21 Case Studies of Social Commerce Impact (yes…real $$)

September 24th, 2008 by Sam Decker Chief Marketing Officer

We didn’t invent the term “Social Commerce.” but we certainly have driven the visibility and clarified the meaning of the term over the past couple years. Unlike other “social” terms, the point of social commerce (and our company) is driving participation between your customers (social) in ways that drives real operational results (commerce). I wrote an article about the meaning of social commerce placed in eConsultancy and iMedia over a year ago.

So it’s natural that we are fanatic about measuring the real impact (in terms of P&L) of our solutions. In fact, we have over 40 case studies, and have published 21 of them (so far) to our web site. Many more are coming related to the impact of Ask & Answer, Stories, and international deployments of our social commerce solutions.

While these case studies are listed on our site, many have asked for them and may not have seen them. So, I thought you may find it useful to see the list here. We also have PDFs of these case studies if you’d like them. Just email info (at) bazaarvoice.com, or you can download them directly from the site. Also, check out our white papers and research.

  1. Customer reviews drive 196% increase in paid search revenue for Office Depot
  2. Reviews help Cars.com drive “intent to buy”
  3. Huge French retailer, Mistergooddeal, drives 40% conversion increase
  4. User-generated content drives sales for Zales
  5. Ratings & Reviews drive conversions for UK retailer
  6. Ratings and reviews increase time on site
  7. Reviews significantly reduce return rates
  8. Paradox of choice
  9. Customer review content in email marketing drives sales
  10. SearchVoice Reviews quickly increases natural search traffic
  11. SearchVoice Reviews drives organic customer acquisition
  12. Use Net Promoters scores to identify solid influencers
  13. Photo reviews drive conversion, enhance customer experience
  14. “Sort by Rating” option drives conversion for Golfsmith
  15. “Customer Favorite” categories drives sales
  16. Social navigation drives sales at PETCO.com
  17. Omniture/Bazaarvoice help major online retailer uncover results
  18. The Answer Den drives orders, traffic, and sales results for PETCO.com
  19. Ask & Answer attracts new users, increases conversion
  20. Ask & Answer™ decreases product-related support costs
  21. philosophy drives new site traffic with Mother’s Day campaign using Bazaarvoice Stories

Sam Decker The CFO’s Favorite Marketing Program in Tough Times

September 23rd, 2008 by Sam Decker Chief Marketing Officer

You have probably read and seen enough in the news about impending recessionary times. If nothing else, the media’s coverage may create a self-fulfilling prophecy by changing our purchasing habits!

Usually the CFO has a louder voice during tough times. Investments and expenses are scrutinized. They’re looking for cost-cutting programs and investments that grow revenue scaling against operating expenses.

So what marketing investments do you make when planning for difficult times?

When marketers talk in terms of opex scaling, the finance department perks up like you served them a double latte. With scaling, costs either decrease over time as revenue stays flat or increases, or costs don’t increase as quickly as revenue does. Therefore, revenue may grow year over year at 20%, but operating expenses grow only at 15%…thus netting 5% higher net profits.

CFOs like revenues, but they’re even more interested in profit and margin dollars. PE ratios and most methods of valuation are based on EBITDA and cash flow. Your goal is to show them how you can impact those numbers.

Unfortunately, there’s a problem with most marketing campaigns and site functionality investments during tough economic times. Traditional marketing campaigns aren’t as efficient because the purchasing bar is higher for the consumer. Consumers must have strong reasons to buy. The natural reaction of marketers is to discount products, but this has bigger implications for the brand.

There are also problems with introducing new site functionality during tough times. As employees get stretched thin, they don’t have time to use or optimize the new functionality, so the new, cool function doesn’t end up being the competitive advantage everyone hoped for, and its value depreciates over time.

So, you and the CFO are looking for investments that scale opex (growing revenue and impact while maintaining costs), don’t damage the brand and margins, and don’t require a lot of resources to get up and running.

These are all great reasons to implement user-generated content (UGC) on your site. In fact, consider proposing UGC as both a positive career move and a win for the company, as the ROI will get the thumbs-up from the CFO and the CEO.

Word of mouth: an excuse to buy

We all know that a “dirt cheap” deal can get people to click and check out. The CFO will like the revenue but hate the short-term margins, not to mention the impact to your brand.

But when customers are persuaded by the relevant and credible word of mouth by people like them, they have a new excuse to buy. Discounts aren’t as important when they find a product, service or experience that is a “must-have” based on the reviews they read. Customers feel confident making a purchase when they read reviews, answers and experiences from others.

What’s more, UGC brings new customers to your site while converting the ones who are already there. And promotions that include UGC increase average order value – no mean feat in hard times.
User-generated content is a marketing annuity.

At Bazaarvoice, we have published several case studies proving that more user-generated content – in reviews and questions answered by the community – equals higher conversion, average order value, traffic from SEO, lower returns and new opportunities for merchandising and marketing. We’ve seen conversion rates increase anywhere from 10% to 100%. Return rates (high cost) can drop as much as 67%.

So from day one, every new piece of user-generated content, whether it is a story, Q&A or a review, adds incremental impact (revenue) over time. The CFO can appreciate the concept of net present value and annuity revenue!

UGC (can) require very little effort

Bazaarvoice clients can immediately see the impact of UGC and start to leverage it. UGC is a highly leveraged investment because your customers are creating the content that helps sell products, so with a small percentage of one person’s time, you have a program that grows in impact (scaling!).

UGC costs stay relatively flat

Traditional marketing programs and campaigns only scale moderately, and that’s only if the costs per impression decreases or the advertising effectiveness increases. There is room to optimize campaigns; however, to bring in more customers, you typically need to increase costs proportionately.

With a hosted UGC solution, companies can predict their monthly costs and yet the potential revenue impact actually grows over time – the more UGC you accumulate, the better your revenue results get. You can then multiply the scaling by using UGC in more marketing tactics such as email campaigns. So, UGC offers a one-two punch: it scales itself and fuels your existing marketing programs!

There are two responses to tough times – retreat and cut costs or be intelligently aggressive. When you’re intelligently aggressive, you choose effective marketing investments that hit the “marketing bulls-eye,” driving long-term, sustainable P&L impact.

Investing in a scaling word of mouth program is the best investment you’ll make – before, during and after a recession.

Now, go make friends with the CFO!

Sam Decker Bazaarvoice Summit Cliffnotes #12: PETCO: UGC Goes Multichannel

September 22nd, 2008 by Sam Decker Chief Marketing Officer

This is the twelfth in our series of key takeaways from some of the presentations and panel discussions offered at the Social Commerce Summit in May 2008.

John Lazarchic, VP of eCommerce at PETCO (a Social Commerce Achievement Award winner), has always been a pioneer in making the most of user-generated contentAs one of Bazaarvoice’s first clients, PETCO has continued to innovate with new ways of amplifying their customer voice.

John recommends incorporating customer feedback and opinions into every facet of the business, from the website and email campaigns to in-store signage and printed weekly circulars.

Below is a list of PETCO’s newest UGC initiatives:

  1. Brand Shops – these mini-sites on PETCO.com feature brand-specific customer reviews to build loyalty and engagement (see the KONG shop).
  2. Top Rated Banner Ads – the inclusion of UGC on these ads resulted in 10% better performance
  3. Fully-integrated customer review contest – using Bazaarvoice’s ReStyle technology, PETCO was able to launch a multichannel Valentine’s Day campaign that spurred participation and engaged customers at every touch point in the PETCO experience
  4. The Answer Den – using our Ask & Answer product, PETCO developed a Q&A section on their site that resulted in 100% more orders per session
  5. Top Contributor Loyalty Program – giving incentives and rewards for your most active community members
  6. Mobile Reviews in the future – give customers access to PETCO.com review content in the store or on the road

And of course, watch this space to learn about PETCO’s latest innovations!

Sam Decker Kelly Mooney at Shop.org: Your Brand’s Growth Driver

September 21st, 2008 by Sam Decker Chief Marketing Officer

If you missed Shop.org this year, it was a tremendous event. Key to this event’s consistent success is its high-quality speakers, and Kelly Mooney from Resource Interactive had some terrific insights, as always.
Her presentation gave clear direction to retailers: Ignore the Web at your peril. The Web remains the fastest-growing channel, growing 5X faster than offline. The Web impacts cross-channel shopping, not just e-commerce; it’s expected to impact 50% of offline sales by 2012.
The Web has also started to supplant stores as the preferred purchasing channel, and brands are rapidly reallocating their advertising spend to go where people are spending their time: online. And brands are differentiating themselves online much more rapidly than they are in-store, adding features such as multistore check-out, online customization, outfitting, co-shopping, and ratings and reviews.
Kelly spent much of her presentation time on ratings and reviews. We had no insight into Kelly’s presentation before she began, and were pleasantly surprised to hear her give such weight to customer reviews.
Specifically, Kelly hit upon the multi-purpose marketing opportunities that spring from online ratings and reviews:

  • Reviews in search results are critical point of interaction and traffic driver
  • Reviews act as in-context advertising
  • They create engaging content and decision support
  • They enable opportunities for re-engagement and acknowledgement

In all, Kelly reminds retailers that it’s important to continuously develop online properties – now more than ever. She offers these “Rules of the Road”:

  • Expand the role of the web to be a strategic growth lever
  • Create relevant and integrated cross-channel experiences
  • Map your customers’ purchase journeys to support their needs
  • Reallocate marketing dollars to activities with proven effectiveness and ROI
  • Prioritize and test branded micro-experiences that have high appeal for select customer segments

Right on Kelly! We totally agree, and these are the rules of the road we use to help our clients.